Can Medicare And Medicare Supplement Pay Less On Medical Services Based On Gender

Abstract

IMPORTED: www_commonwealthfund_org____media_images_publications_issue_brief_2017_feb_explorerbutton_biennial_h_100_w_400.png

Issue: Prior to the Affordable Care Act (ACA), one-third of women who tried to buy a wellness program on their own were either turned down, charged a higher premium considering of their health, or had specific health problems excluded from their plans. Beginning in 2010, ACA consumer protections, peculiarly coverage for preventive care screenings with no cost-sharing and a ban on programme benefit limits, improved the quality of health insurance for women. In 2014, the police force's major insurance reforms helped millions of women who did not accept employer insurance to gain coverage through the ACA's marketplaces or through Medicaid.
Goals: To examine the furnishings of ACA wellness reforms on women's coverage and access to care.
Method: Analysis of the Republic Fund Biennial Health Insurance Surveys, 2001–2016.
Findings and Conclusions: Women ages xix to 64 who shopped for new coverage on their ain constitute it significantly easier to notice affordable plans in 2016 compared to 2010. The percentage of women who reported delaying or skipping needed care because of costs fell to an all-time low. Insured women were more than likely than uninsured women to receive preventive screenings, including Pap tests and mammograms.

Background

Compared with men, women on boilerplate accept more interaction with the wellness intendance system over their lifetimes. Not only do women have relatively greater health care needs during their reproductive years, they also often serve as family caregivers and play a cardinal part in analogous the health care needs of multiple generations of family unit members, including children, spouses, and crumbling parents.¹

Accessing wellness care became increasingly challenging for women in the decade prior to the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), as increasing numbers lost insurance coverage. The percentage of adult women under age 65 without insurance climbed from 13 percent in 2001 to 20 percent in 2010 — from 11 million to xix million women (Exhibit 1). Women who lost their employer coverage had few places to turn. In most states, Medicaid was available but to women who were pregnant, parents with very low incomes, or people with disabilities. In the individual insurance market place in nigh states, women could exist charged more for a health program, or denied coverage altogether, based on a preexisting wellness status.

To insurers, women's gender was, in upshot, a preexisting condition that signaled the potential for college health intendance employ and college costs. That is why in most states insurers selling plans in the individual market charged young women higher premiums than young men — to protect themselves from this greater risk. The U.S. Authorities Accountability Office found in 2013 that in 38 states, individual-market plans with the everyman premiums charged a nonsmoking 30-year-old unmarried adult female a higher premium than they charged her male person counterpart.²

Insurers also protected themselves by excluding from coverage services that women would likely need, like maternity care. A 2012 study institute only 12 per centum of plans in the individual marketplace offered maternity coverage, and only nine states required insurers to include this benefit.³ Consequently, women with individual-marketplace plans had less comprehensive policies, on boilerplate, than those with employer coverage. In 2012, the Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance Survey found only 44 pct of women with private-market coverage had motherhood benefits, compared to 81 percentage of women in an employer program (data not shown). And merely 1-third (34%) of privately insured women with individual policies had a programme that covered nativity control or contraceptives, roughly one-half the rate for women (62%) with employer coverage.

The ACA brought about sweeping changes in insurance for women. Considering of the police force, women who buy coverage on their own are no longer charged higher premiums than men in their own age group, can no longer be denied coverage because of preexisting conditions, and must be covered for essential services like maternity care. Tax credits accept helped brand individual plans affordable for women with low or moderate incomes, and millions of women have become eligible for Medicaid. Young women, meanwhile, can stay covered on a parent'south health plan until historic period 26. In addition, all individual plans, including employer plans, cannot identify limits on how much they volition pay annually or over a lifetime, and most plans must comprehend preventive services, including contraception, without toll-sharing.^4,5 1 2015 study found the ACA collectively saved privately insured women about $1.4 billion per twelvemonth on contraception.^half-dozen

This analysis of the 2016 Republic Fund Biennial Wellness Insurance Survey compares women's health insurance and health care experiences in the years before and afterwards the ACA'southward major coverage expansions in 2014.

Survey Findings

The Uninsured Rate for Women Is at an All-time Low

Past 2016, the number of working-historic period women (ages 19–64) lacking health insurance had fallen by most half since 2010, from 19 meg to 11 million, or from xx percent to eleven percent of this population (Exhibit one, Appendix 1). Women with low incomes have made peculiarly large gains: uninsured rates for those with incomes below 200 percent of the federal poverty level ($23,760 for an private or $48,600 for a family of four), fell from 34 pct in 2010 to 18 percentage in 2016 (Exhibit two). The findings are like for low-income women of all races and ethnicities.

Of all age groups, women 19 to 34 have seen the greatest improvements in their coverage (Showroom iii). In 2010, 25 percentage of young women reported existence uninsured, compared to 14 percent in 2016. The early on improvements seen in 2012 reflected young adults' contempo ability to stay on a parent's policy until historic period 26. Later on 2014, young women made further gains through the expansion of Medicaid eligibility, new subsidies for private coverage, and reforms of the private marketplace.

This broader availability of affordable insurance has led to striking changes in women'southward coverage. In 2010, just 5 pct of working-historic period women had coverage through the private market and just 10 percentage had Medicaid (Exhibit 4). By 2016, the share of women with individual coverage had doubled and the share with Medicaid had climbed to fifteen percent.

But coverage options are more limited for women in the nineteen states that take not yet expanded eligibility for Medicaid, and consequently uninsured rates are oftentimes much college. In Texas, for example, women are uninsured at nearly five times the rate in New York and one and a half times the rate in California, both of which expanded Medicaid under the ACA (Exhibit 5). And women in Florida, which like Texas chose not to expand Medicaid, are also uninsured at much college rates than those living in California and New York.

Reforms Accept Made Information technology Easier for Women to Purchase Health Plans on Their Own

The ACA'south consumer protections and subsidies for individual-market coverage have particularly benefited women. In 2010, one-third of women who had a health plan or tried to buy one in the private marketplace in the prior iii years had either been turned down by an insurance company, charged a college premium because of their health, or had a specific health problem excluded from coverage.^seven Among women with health problems, 46 percent reported 1 or more of these problems. In the end, fewer than one-half (46%) of women who had tried to buy a programme ended up enrolling (Exhibit 6).

By 2016, things had improved significantly. The proportion of women who had shopped for a plan in the individual market and ultimately enrolled in i climbed to more than than 2-thirds (67%) (Exhibit 6). And the proportion reporting difficulty finding an affordable programme fell by nearly half. At that place was similar improvement in the share of women experiencing trouble finding a plan that fit their needs. Women with health problems made particularly big gains (Appendix two).

Fewer Women Are Skipping or Delaying Needed Care Considering of Costs

Gains in health insurance coverage accept led to nationwide improvements in measures of health care access for women. In 2010, nearly half (48%) of women ages 19 to 64, or an estimated 45 meg people, reported non getting needed care because of the cost, including they had not filled a prescription, not seen a specialist when needed, skipped a recommended medical test or treatment, or not gone to a doctor when ill (Exhibit seven, Appendix 3). By 2016, the share of women reporting whatsoever one of these toll-related issues getting needed care cruel to 38 percent, or about 37 one thousand thousand people (Showroom seven, Appendix three, and Appendix 4).

Access to prescription drugs for women with wellness issues also significantly improved betwixt 2010 and 2016. In 2010, 31 percent of women who reported having one of five chronic wellness bug or being in fair or poor health reported not filling a prescription for their condition because of costs (data not shown).^viii Past 2016, this charge per unit had fallen to 21 per centum (Appendix 4).

Fewer Women Are Reporting Medical Nib Bug

Expanded coverage has also led to modest declines in medically related financial problems. In 2012, 47 pct of women, or 44 million, reported either having a problem paying a medical nib, being contacted by a collection agency for unpaid medical bills, having to change their way of life to pay medical bills, or that they were paying off medical debt over time (Exhibit 8, Appendix iii). In 2016, 42 per centum of women, or 40 million, reported having a medical pecker problem in the past yr or medical debt (Exhibit eight, Appendix 3, and Appendix 5).

However, after substantial improvement on these indicators of fiscal stress in 2014, there was little improvement, and even erosion on some measures, in 2016. Most notably, the share of women who reported they were paying off medical debt over time rose significantly. Rates of medical debt in 2016 were highest among women with private insurance, both employer-based and individual-market, and among women with disabilities covered through Medicare. Rates were lowest for women with Medicaid coverage. As on all measures of medical pecker issues, women are more likely than men to say they are paying off medical debt over time (information not shown).

Insured Women Are More Probable to Receive Preventive Care

Enquiry shows increased use of preventive services saves lives. For example, increasing the share of women 40 and older who receive breast cancer screening every 2 years to 90 percent could save 3,700 lives annually, while increasing the number of young women who receive chlamydia screening to that level would save an estimated 30,000 lives.^nine A 2015 report institute that the ACA's dependent-coverage provision was associated with higher early on detection of cervical cancer in young women ages 21 to 25.¹⁰ Some other recent study showed that early on detection of breast cancer has also improved post-ACA.¹¹

Our survey findings indicate the difference insurance makes in whether women receive timely preventive care and cancer screenings. Women ages xl to 64 continuously insured for the full year were significantly more likely than uninsured women to have had a mammogram within the past two years (Exhibit 9, Appendix 4). And insured women 21 and older were somewhat more probable than uninsured women to accept received a Pap test in the past three years. This narrower gap may be a consequence of women'southward widespread access to contraception and affordable cancer screening through clinics like those run by Planned Parenthood, where 79 percent of patients have incomes at or below 150 percent of poverty, and through the Centers for Illness Control and Prevention's National Chest and Cervical Cancer Early Detection Program.¹² In 2014 solitary, Planned Parenthood provided more than 270,000 Pap tests to women.^xiii

Insurance also makes a divergence in women'southward access to primary care and other preventive services. For example, insured women were more likely to study having a regular doctor and having their blood pressure level and cholesterol checked in the recommended time frame (Showroom 10, Appendix 4).

Determination

The Affordable Care Human activity has improved health intendance for women and their families through the police force'due south insurance market reforms, mandatory coverage of gratis preventive care, and subsidized, comprehensive insurance options for people defective access to affordable employer coverage.

Particularly important for young women and their families have been the requirements that insurers in the individual market place offer a comprehensive benefit package with maternity coverage and that nearly private plans embrace contraception. Some observers have claimed that maternity coverage has been a commuter of higher premiums in the individual marketplace, but enquiry shows otherwise. Eibner and Whaley found that cutting maternity benefits from the ACA'due south essential benefit package would lower premiums by merely 4 pct, but doing so would significantly increment costs to women having babies.¹⁴ Without maternity coverage, a family unit'due south out-of-pocket costs would jump by roughly one,000 percent to nigh 3,000 percent, depending on the complexity of a delivery.

But the Commonwealth Fund survey findings likewise suggest that more work needs to be washed to make health care attainable and affordable for all U.Southward. women. First, an estimated eleven 1000000 working-historic period women remain uninsured. The xix states that have yet to aggrandize Medicaid eligibility could bring critical coverage to low-income women in their states by moving frontward with expansion. State and federal outreach and enrollment efforts also have been shown to increment awareness of and enrollment in Medicaid or marketplace coverage among the remaining uninsured. And national clearing reform or a loosening of restrictions for undocumented immigrants' eligibility for Medicaid and market plans would assistance to lower the much higher uninsured rates of Latinas.^fifteen

Second, although reforms to the individual marketplace have made finding affordable health insurance coverage significantly easier, one-3rd of women still experience difficulty. One option to improve the affordability of programme premiums is to extend eligibility for taxation credits to people earning more than 400 per centum of poverty (nearly $50,000 for an individual and $98,000 for a family of iv). This simple alter could bring coverage to 1.2 million currently uninsured people, at a relatively minor annual federal cost of $6 billion.^sixteen

And while we have seen declines in price-related obstacles to getting needed care and reductions in medical neb issues, rates remain very high. What is probable necessary is a fundamental redesign of private insurance, including employer plans, then that deductibles and toll-sharing encourage, rather than discourage, people to seek timely health care and exercise not get out people burdened with debt when they do seek care.

In the backwash of Congress'southward failed endeavour to repeal and supervene upon the ACA, the about immediate business organisation for policymakers is ensuring that the 17 million to xviii million people with marketplace coverage are able to enroll this fall. Congress could take three key modest steps toward this stop:

A permanent cribbing for payments to insurers that, by law, must offer cost-sharing reductions for low-income enrollees in the marketplaces.
A fallback health plan pick for the fewer than 20 counties where consumers may not have a programme to cull from this fall.
Reinsurance to assist carriers cover unexpectedly high claims costs.¹⁷

The Trump administration can also play an important part by signaling to insurers participating in the marketplaces that it will enforce the individual mandate. The administration besides tin can help by affirming its commitment to ensuring that all eligible Americans have the tools they need to enroll in the coverage that is correct for them.

How We Conducted This Study

The Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance Survey, 2016, was conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates International from July 12 to November 20, 2016. The survey consisted of 25-infinitesimal telephone interviews in English or Spanish conducted amongst a random, nationally representative sample of six,005 adults age nineteen and older living in the continental United States. A combination of landline and cellular phone random-digit dial samples was used to accomplish people. In all, 2,402 interviews were conducted with respondents on landline telephones and iii,603 interviews were conducted on cell phones, including ii,262 with respondents who alive in households with no landline telephone access.

The sample was designed to generalize to the U.S. adult population and to allow divide analyses of responses of low-income households. This report limits the analysis to respondents ages 19 to 64 (n=4,186). Statistical results were weighted to correct for the stratified sample design, the overlapping landline and prison cell phone sample frames, and disproportionate nonresponse that might bias results. The information are weighted to the U.S. adult population past age, sex, race/ethnicity, instruction, household size, geographic region, population density, and household telephone use, using the U.South. Census Agency's 2016 Annual Social and Economic Supplement.

The resulting weighted sample is representative of the approximately 187.four million U.Due south. adults ages nineteen to 64. The survey has an overall margin of sampling fault of +/– i.nine percentage points at the 95 per centum confidence level. The landline portion of the survey achieved a 14 pct response rate and the prison cell phone component accomplished a 10 percent response rate.

Nosotros as well written report estimates from the 2001, 2003, 2005, 2010, 2012, and 2014 Commonwealth Fund Biennial Wellness Insurance Surveys. These surveys were conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates International using the same stratified sampling strategy that was used in 2016, except the 2001, 2003, and 2005 surveys did not include a cell phone random-digit dial sample. In 2001, the survey was conducted from Apr 27 through July 29, 2001, and included 2,829 adults ages xix to 64; in 2003, the survey was conducted from September iii, 2003, through January 4, 2004, and included three,293 adults ages 19 to 64; in 2005, the survey was conducted from August 18, 2005, to January 5, 2006, amongst 3,352 adults ages 19 to 64; in 2010, the survey was conducted from July xiv to November 30, 2010, among 3,033 adults ages 19 to 64; in 2012, the survey was conducted from April 26 to Baronial 19, 2012, amongst 3,393 adults ages 19 to 64; and in 2014, the survey was conducted from July 22 to December 14, 2014, among four,251 adults ages 19 to 64.